Set against the backdrop of a caste-ridden society, Bharatipura delves into the idealism of Jagannatha, a man whose philosophy is as well-intentioned as it is misguided. Having recently returned from England, he attempts to apply Western models of social justice to his village's deeply entrenched caste system. He is aware of the struggles of communities like the Black population in the West and wants to initiate similar change for the Holeyaru, the community of manual scavengers.
Jagannatha's efforts are futile because he fails to grasp how social movements gain momentum. While he aims to lead a strong agitation, he discovers he is a lone crusader. The novel expertly highlights how the injustice of the caste system has been internalized by both the upper castes and the Dalits, with neither group showing a true willingness to change.
His well-intentioned initiatives fail because the very people he seeks to uplift are not prepared to embrace his cause. This resistance is rooted in collective fear and social inertia. The profound depth of this subjugation is underscored by the fact that the Dalit god, Bhutharaya, is considered a mere servant to Manjunatha, the deity of the upper castes.
The novel also presents a crucial counterpoint from an upper-caste "reformer" who astutely observes the power the Holeyaru hold. He questions what would happen if they weaponized their "untouchability" by refusing to clean the temple town's human waste. This insight highlights a more practical, albeit confrontational, path to reform.
Ultimately, Bharatipura is less about social injustice itself and more about the internal conflict of its protagonist. Jagannatha is an alienated hero, a misfit challenging the social fabric of his community. He faces intense opposition from the upper castes and a frustrating lack of enthusiasm from the very people he wants to help. The book is a complex exploration of social change and can be read as a cautionary tale on what not to attempt, even with the purest of intentions.
Comments
Post a Comment